Some antidepressants, asthma and epilepsy medications can also make your tremor worse. Always check the patient information leaflet that comes with medications to see if they are thought to cause or worsen tremor.
DBS passes a small current at high frequency through precisely targeted areas of the brain which appears to block motor symptoms. DBS is not suitable for everyone. This surgery and its potential risks and benefits should always be discussed with an experienced doctor. See also, Deep brain stimulation DBS. Our thanks to Parkinson's UK for permission to use the following source s in compiling this information:.
At first you may be prescribed only low doses of medication. Or your doctor may suggest you delay taking medication until symptoms increase. Stress is a state of physical, mental or emotional strain or tension that can affect anyone at any stage of life.
Accept Decline. Motor symptoms Motor symptoms are those that are related to movement, such as tremor, freezing and rigidity. Types of tremor There are two main types of tremor: Physiological tremor normal tremor - this occurs in all of us and is quite normal, for example when an outstretched limb is held against gravity. These tremors are usually classified, or described, according to the circumstances in which they arise, for example: rest tremor which occurs when a body part is completely at rest and supported such as a hand supported by an armchair.
This usually, but not always, stops when an intended action is carried out action tremor which occurs when an intended movement is made, such as moving a limb from one point to another or when a particular posture is maintained. Action tremor seen when the limb is held in posture is called postural tremor. Management of tremor There is no cure for tremor, but there are many ways to manage it. Coping strategies Many people have discovered and developed strategies that help them to reduce or overcome tremor — their own personal coping strategies.
Throwing ball to stop tremor - watch our video Flicking the hands - watch our video Bouncing a ball and running - watch our video Bouncing ball to assist with turning - watch our video Holding hands to calm tremor - watch our video Reducing tremor by gripping - watch our video Juggling apples to control tremor - watch our video Twirling a pen to reduce tremor - watch our video.
Doctors may give you medications to treat these symptoms. Sleep problems and sleep disorders. People with Parkinson's disease often have sleep problems, including waking up frequently throughout the night, waking up early or falling asleep during the day. People may also experience rapid eye movement sleep behavior disorder, which involves acting out your dreams. Medications may help your sleep problems.
Because the cause of Parkinson's is unknown, proven ways to prevent the disease also remain a mystery. Some research has shown that regular aerobic exercise might reduce the risk of Parkinson's disease. Some other research has shown that people who consume caffeine — which is found in coffee, tea and cola — get Parkinson's disease less often than those who don't drink it. Green tea is also related to a reduced risk of developing Parkinson's disease.
However, it is still not known whether caffeine actually protects against getting Parkinson's, or is related in some other way. Currently there is not enough evidence to suggest drinking caffeinated beverages to protect against Parkinson's.
Parkinson's disease care at Mayo Clinic. Mayo Clinic does not endorse companies or products. Advertising revenue supports our not-for-profit mission. This content does not have an English version. This content does not have an Arabic version. Overview Parkinson's disease is a progressive nervous system disorder that affects movement. Request an Appointment at Mayo Clinic. Share on: Facebook Twitter. Show references Jameson JL, et al.
Parkinson's disease. In: Harrison's Principles of Internal Medicine. The McGraw-Hill Companies; Accessed May 26, Parkinson's disease: Hope through research. National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke. Ferri FF. Parkinson disease. In: Ferri's Clinical Advisor A Spatial covariance pattern identified by ordinal trends canonical variate analysis of FDG PET data from 11 hemispheres of nine patients with tremor-dominant Parkinson's disease PD scanned on and off posterior VL stimulation labelled ventral intermediate nucleus in the original manuscript.
B The expression of this Parkinson's disease tremor-related metabolic pattern PDTP was reduced by posterior VL stimulation in 10 of the 11 treated hemispheres. These data show that metabolic activity in both the cortico-cerebellar circuit and the basal ganglia is related to tremor severity. Reprinted from Mure et al. These studies compared tremor-dominant Parkinson's disease with either non-tremor patients with Parkinson's disease Benninger et al. Tremor-dominant patients had reduced grey matter volume in the right cerebellum Benninger et al.
These findings fit with the involvement of the cerebello-thalamo-cortical network in tremor, as shown with functional imaging Deiber et al. It is unclear how increased activation of these areas can translate in both reduced and increased grey matter volume. This divergence might be explained by differences in neuroplasticity between brain regions, which—in the context of skill acquisition—can produce opposite volumetric changes in the cortex and basal ganglia Kloppel et al.
Taken together, these findings provide evidence for the involvement of both the cerebello-thalamo-cortical circuit and the basal ganglia in Parkinson's disease resting tremor. The arrest of tremor by focused interventions in either of these circuits further confirms that both are causally related to tremor.
There are no studies directly comparing the effects of these two targets, but one study reported an additional reduction of tremor scores after STN-DBS in patients with Parkinson's disease with previous thalamic surgery Fraix et al. Several hypotheses have been put forward to explain the occurrence of resting tremor in Parkinson's disease.
As outlined above, there is evidence that both the basal ganglia and the cerebello-thalamo-cortical circuit are implicated in tremor. However, most models are based on detailed recordings in a limited set of neurons e. Therefore, most models focus on a node in a single circuit and interpret the changes in other circuits as secondary.
Here we will place concurrent changes in two separate circuits into perspective. This section also updates and elaborates on earlier reviews about the pathophysiology of parkinsonian tremor Elble, ; Deuschl et al. These two frequencies coincide with the frequency of physiological tremor and Parkinson's disease tremor, respectively. The key assumption of this model is that single thalamic neurons, not the basal ganglia circuitry, form the tremor pacemaker.
However, in vivo measurements in the thalamus of patients with Parkinson's disease have questioned the presence of these thalamic pacemaker cells. In contrast, a second study found a convincing low threshold calcium spike bursts pattern in a larger number of cells in the thalamus both the anterior and posterior VL of patients with Parkinson's disease Magnin et al.
However, low-threshold calcium spike bursts were present both in patients with tremor-dominant and akinetic Parkinson's disease, and the bursts were not coherent with peripheral tremor recordings. Patients with tremor-dominant Parkinson's disease showed distinct tremor-locked bursts without low-threshold calcium spike bursts characteristics in the posterior VL, but not in the anterior VL. These findings could be taken as evidence that pathological low-threshold calcium spike bursting is not related to tremor.
Alternatively, thalamic low-threshold calcium spike bursts might be transformed into tremor-locked bursts by re-entry properties of the thalamo-cortical circuit Magnin et al. Another issue concerns the mechanisms that drive thalamic cells into an oscillatory mode in Parkinson's disease. In theory, any mechanism that engenders membrane hyperpolarization, whether through reduction of excitatory drive dysfacilitation or excess inhibition, will trigger low-frequency rhythmicity of thalamic neurons Llinas et al.
Several different mechanisms have been suggested. First, according to the classical model of Parkinson's disease Albin et al. However, this mechanism would predict a predominant role for the pallidal thalamus, anterior VL, in tremor genesis. This does not fit with findings from DBS, which show that interference with the cerebellar thalamus, posterior VL, is superior for treating tremor Atkinson et al.
Second, it has recently been proposed that increased inhibitory input from the zona incerta towards the posterior VL could hyperpolarize these thalamic neurons Plaha et al. The zona incerta is located in the subthalamic region, medially with respect to the STN. In non-human primates, the zona incerta receives projections from the internal globus pallidus [although mainly the cognitive division Sidibe et al. This makes the zona incerta an interface between the basal ganglia and the cerebello-thalamo-cortical circuits, and its involvement in tremor may explain why both circuits are related to tremor.
In line with this hypothesis, DBS of the zona incerta can reduce tremor Plaha et al. Third, thalamic posterior VL neurons may be hyperpolarized through the cerebellum. Moreover, the finding of disynaptic projections from the STN to the cerebellar cortex in non-human primates Bostan et al.
Fourth, it is possible that hyperpolarization of thalamic posterior VL neurons is related to the degeneration of dopaminergic projections from the midbrain to the posterior VL. Specifically, both the retrorubral area [that is degenerated in tremor-dominant Parkinson's disease Hirsch et al. According to this hypothesis, basal ganglia dysfunction would not be required for the hyperpolarization of posterior VL neurons.
This hypothesis Pare et al. The key feature of this hypothesis is that the tremor pacemaker is primarily located in the basal ganglia pallidum , with pallido-thalamic interactions determining the net frequency of the tremor. However, high-frequency stimulation of the pallidum did not spread to the motor cortex Rivlin-Etzion et al. This makes it unlikely that high-frequency oscillations in the basal ganglia drive Parkinson's disease resting tremor Rivlin-Etzion et al. Other work also questions the specific role of high-frequency basal ganglia oscillations in the generation of tremor.
Therefore, most authors relate the increased high-frequency 8—35 Hz oscillations in the basal ganglia of patients with Parkinson's disease to akinesia, but not to tremor Rivlin-Etzion et al. This hypothesis Plenz and Kital, is again based on in vitro data and proposes that the STN and external globus pallidus constitute a central pacemaker that is modulated by striatal inhibition of external globus pallidus neurons.
This pacemaker could be responsible for synchronized oscillatory activity in the normal and pathological basal ganglia. However, these oscillations occurred at frequencies between 0. Thus, it is not possible to test whether these oscillations are consistently coherent with tremor, and hence this hypothesis suffers from the same critique as Model 2.
This hypothesis Bergman et al. This could lead to excessive synchronization in the basal ganglia, possibly because inhibitory collaterals in the pallidum are affected by dopamine depletion Bevan et al. The key feature of this model is that the basal ganglia circuitry, not the thalamus, forms the tremor pacemaker.
In line with this hypothesis, parkinsonian primates show less selective neuronal responses to proprioceptive stimulation in the entire pallido-thalamo-cortical loop Filion et al. These changes were found to be larger in the pallidum of patients with tremor-dominant than non-tremor Parkinson's disease Levy et al.
However, as already mentioned, the inconsistent coherence between basal ganglia oscillations and tremor Hurtado et al. Taken together, the different models discussed above position the tremor pacemaker either in the thalamus Model 1 or in the basal ganglia Models 2—4.
Since the cerebellar not pallidal thalamus is primarily involved in parkinsonian tremor, the thalamic pacemaker hypothesis does not account for the mechanisms that trigger thalamic oscillations, and it remains unclear whether these mechanisms have any relationship with basal ganglia dysfunction. On the other hand, the basal ganglia pacemaker hypotheses are more directly linked to the core pathophysiological substrate of Parkinson's disease, but these models struggle with the fact that tremor-related oscillations in the basal ganglia are only transient and inconsistent in nature.
Given the well-known role of both the basal ganglia and the cerebello-thalamic circuits in tremor, we aimed to construct a model that specifies and integrates the role of both circuits in tremor Helmich et al.
To test this systems-level view on tremor, we used functional MRI to identify cerebral responses that co-fluctuated with spontaneous variations in tremor amplitude, as measured with EMG during scanning van Duinen et al. These abrupt amplitude fluctuations are very characteristic of parkinsonian tremor, and they do not occur, for example, in essential tremor Elble and Koller, ; Gao, ; Ropper and Samuels, This method also allowed us to quantify functional interactions between the basal ganglia and the cerebello-thalamo-cortical circuit.
We obtained the following results Fig. On the basis of these data, we suggest the following model, which is also illustrated in Fig. The novel aspect of this model is that it offers a mechanism explaining how the basal ganglia and the cerebello-thalamo-cortical circuits interact with each other. Tremor amplitude- and onset-related cerebral activity in Parkinson's disease. Right: Regions of interest in the basal ganglia are shown. Left: These two tremor-related effects are illustrated for the motor cortex of one patient.
Right: These two tremor-related effects are shown for the motor cortex across the whole group 19 tremor-dominant patients , separately for the most- and least-affected hemisphere. Similar effects were found in the posterior VL and cerebellum not shown. Left: This effect is illustrated for the internal globus pallidus of one patient.
Right: This effect is shown for the internal globus pallidus GPi across the whole group 19 tremor-dominant patients , separately for the most- and least-affected hemisphere.
Similar effects were found for the putamen, but not for the caudate not shown. These data suggest distinct contributions of two circuits to tremor: the cerebello-thalamo-cortical circuit controls tremor amplitude, and the striato-pallidal circuit produces changes in tremor amplitude. The dimmer-switch model of parkinsonian resting tremor. In tremor-dominant Parkinson's disease, dopaminergic cell death in the retrorubral area A8 causes dopamine depletion in the pallidum in red.
Pallidal dopamine depletion leads to emergence of pathological activity in the striato-pallidal circuit, which triggers activity in the cerebello-thalamo-cortical circuit in blue through the primary motor cortex red line between pallidum and primary motor cortex.
Thus, the striato-pallidal circuit triggers tremor episodes analogues to a light switch , while the cerebello-thalamo-cortical circuit produces the tremor and controls its amplitude analogous to a light dimmer. This model is based on Helmich et al. This revealed that pallidal, but not striatal, dopamine depletion correlates with the severity of resting tremor.
This finding could solve the dopaminergic paradox of Parkinson's disease resting tremor. Specifically, the pallidum receives distinct dopaminergic projections from the substantia nigra pars compacta Smith et al.
This pattern of divergence and convergence makes it unlikely that midbrain pathology can produce either pure striatal or pure pallidal dopamine depletion although the degree of dopamine depletion in each area may vary between patients.
Thus, patients with Parkinson's disease with resting tremor will generally have some degree of striatal dopamine depletion, explaining why the presence of striatal dopamine depletion appears required for developing resting tremor Deuschl et al. Indeed, if pallidal but not striatal dopamine depletion is involved in tremor genesis, this could also explain why striatal DAT signal is not correlated with tremor severity.
The dimmer-switch model combines several features of the previous hypotheses into a larger explanatory framework. First, loss of segregation in the dopamine-depleted pallidum may be a mechanism that explains both the emergence of pathological activity in the basal ganglia, and the increased connectivity between basal ganglia and motor cortex Rivlin-Etzion et al.
Second, altered basal ganglia output may influence neurons in the cerebellar thalamus posterior VL via the motor cortex.
That is, excitatory cortico-thalamic projections from motor cortex to ventrolateral thalamus Fonnum et al. This model would explain why basal ganglia oscillations are only transient and inconsistent, why thalamic oscillations are highly synchronous with the tremor, and thus why both basal ganglia and the cerebello-thalamo-cortical circuit are causally related to tremor.
It remains to be shown why posterior VL neurons are more prone to develop tremor oscillations than anterior VL neurons, since both regions receive cortico-thalamic projections from the motor cortex. Hypothetically, the connections between the posterior VL and the cerebellum are a prerequisite for the development of tremor oscillations.
With the methods functional MRI employed in our previous paper Helmich et al. The presence of tremor oscillations in the STN that are coherent with peripheral tremor activity Levy et al. In contrast to the pallidum, the STN receives direct anatomical projections from the motor cortex Nambu et al. The STN also sends disynaptic anatomical projections to the cerebellar cortex Bostan et al. Therefore, the STN has both afferent and efferent connections with the cerebello-thalamo-cortical tremor circuit.
Whether the STN is part of the basal ganglia trigger, or whether the STN is involved in the cerebello-thalamo-cortical circuit producing the tremor, remains to be investigated in future studies using high-resolution MRI in combination with connectivity analyses.
Although our methods functional MRI enabled a systems-level view on tremor, we could not detect oscillatory activity at tremor frequency. Therefore, it remains an open question which brain region s determine the tremor frequency. The cerebello-thalamo-cortical tremor network we identified matches closely the network identified in studies that have directly tracked cerebral changes occurring at resting-tremor frequency using magneto-encephalography; Fig.
Thus, in our view, it is the cerebello-thalamo-cortical network that is the ultimate tremor generator, but as influenced and triggered by the coupled basal ganglia network. Accordingly, a novel DBS paradigm that takes these network properties into account was found to be more successful than standard DBS in reducing both Parkinson's disease symptoms and tremor oscillations in the internal globus pallidus Rosin et al.
This new paradigm, termed closed-loop DBS, uses a trigger detected in a reference structure M1 as the input to deliver DBS trains to the stimulated structure internal globus pallidus. These data show that the interconnectivity between various participating brain areas plays a crucial role in the emergence of pathological oscillations and clinical symptoms. Based on our model, we suspect that the intermittent oscillations in the basal ganglia Fig.
Most previous studies did not take tremor amplitude fluctuations into account, but focused on cycle-by-cycle coherence between neural and muscular activity, i. In a preliminary study in one patient with Parkinson's disease, the authors recorded local field potentials from the STN and related them to changes in tremor amplitude, as measured with EMG Wang et al. They found that beta suppression in the STN preceded the onset of tremor episodes and made way for oscillations at tremor frequency in the STN.
If activity in the beta band is a way by which the sensorimotor system maintains the status quo Gilbertson et al. On the other hand, since beta suppression in the cortex Crone et al. In our model, pallidal activity was related to changes in tremor amplitude, rather than the amplitude of the tremor itself Fig.
This raises the question how the severity of pallidal dopamine depletion could predict clinical tremor severity Fig.
This likely depends on the effect of dopamine depletion on pallidal activity. For example, dopamine depletion may increase the amplitude of tremor onset-related activity in the pallidum. This should lead to more abrupt tremor changes, but not to increased tremor amplitude. Second, dopamine depletion may increase the rate of onset-related activity in the pallidum.
More frequent episodes of pallidal activity could lead to more frequent tremor episodes, but also, if the bursts of pallidal activity occur shortly after each other, to amplified activity in the cerebello-thalamo-cortical circuit and hence to increased tremor amplitude.
Finally, more severe pallidal dopamine depletion may lead to enhanced connectivity between the basal ganglia and the cerebello-thalamo-cortical systems. This would make the cerebello-thalamo-cortical circuit more susceptible to perturbing signals from the basal ganglia, and the increased input—output relationship may lead to more severe tremor.
Using metabolic imaging, several groups have found a correlation between tremor amplitude and cerebral activity in the cerebellum, motor cortex and posterior VL e. Deiber et al. One interpretational problem is that the limited temporal resolution of these techniques makes it difficult to determine whether the cerebral effects are causal or reactive to the tremor.
Electrophysiological studies, which have a much higher temporal resolution, partly suffer from the same problem. That is, single-cell recordings in the thalamus, STN and internal globus pallidus of patients with Parkinson's disease show that many neurons with tremor-related activity also respond to somatosensory stimulation Lenz et al. Therefore, neural activity that leads peripheral tremor activity might also relate to the preceding tremor beat. Conduction times are not helpful to disentangle cause from effect, given the diverse pathways through which afferent input can reach the basal ganglia and thalamus.
Nevertheless, there are also thalamic cells that do not respond to somatosensory stimulation, and that show tremulous activity preceding muscular activity Lenz et al. This suggests that the thalamus has a causal role in tremor.
Other electrophysiological studies have calculated the oscillatory activity at tremor or double tremor frequency of single neurons or larger groups of neurons, for example using subcortical DBS electrodes or cortical magnetoencephalography recordings Levy et al.
Since oscillations are defined over longer temporal windows, this procedure makes it difficult to determine whether neural oscillations drive the tremor or vice versa. Analytical methods including the phase of coherence or Granger causality might help to solve this problem Timmermann et al.
To reliably disentangle cause from effect, interference studies are helpful. Lesion studies provide strong evidence that activity in the posterior VL is causally linked to tremor: thalamotomy, posterior VL-DBS and thalamic stroke lead to immediate tremor arrest Benabid et al. The motor cortex is the only region of the cerebello-thalamo-cortical circuit that has a direct access to the spinal cord, and therefore it seems plausible that activity in this area drives the tremor.
Accordingly, interference with M1 activity using transcranial magnetic stimulation can reset resting tremor in Parkinson's disease Ni et al.
In contrast, transcranial magnetic stimulation over the cerebellum did not reset tremor, suggesting that this region does not directly drive the tremor.
Lesion studies support this idea: cerebellar stroke Kim et al. Therefore, the role of the cerebellum in tremor may be modulatory rather than causal. Accordingly, a previous magnetoencephalography study showed that oscillatory activity in the cerebellum is coherent with thalamic and motor activity, but not with the tremor itself Timmermann et al.
This suggests that the cerebellum does not have a direct efferent or afferent relationship with peripheral tremor. This relationship could be different for other tremor pathologies. For example, other than in Parkinson's disease, cerebellar stroke can ameliorate ipsilateral essential tremor Dupuis et al. Finally, an approach to gain mechanistic insights into the role of altered oscillations in Parkinson's disease has been to stimulate the basal ganglia or thalamus at precisely these frequencies, using implanted DBS electrodes.
A characteristic feature of Parkinson's disease resting tremor is its decrease during voluntary movements Deuschl et al. This feature is routinely used in clinical practice to distinguish resting tremor from other tremor forms Deuschl et al. However, the neural mechanisms underlying the interaction between voluntary movements and resting tremor remain unclear. As outlined above, parkinsonian tremor results from altered responses in both the basal ganglia and the cerebello-thalamo-cortical circuit.
This indicates that voluntary movements may interact with resting tremor in either or both of these circuits. We recently investigated the cerebral interactions between motor planning and Parkinson's disease resting tremor. To this end, we used a motor imagery paradigm as a quantifiable proxy of motor planning while measuring tremor-related activity during functional MRI scanning. This procedure avoids the confounding effects of somatosensory reafference associated with the production of voluntary movements.
There were two main findings: i planning- and tremor-related responses overlapped in the posterior VL, but not in the cerebellum or in the motor cortex and ii tremor amplitude was unaffected by motor imagery Helmich et al. This indicates that motor planning-related activity in the posterior VL does not remove tremor-related responses in this region, possibly because both processes involve partly different neuronal populations Lenz et al.
Another study directly assessed the electrophysiological interactions between motor execution and Parkinson's disease resting tremor Hallett et al. The pattern of alternating activity in agonist and antagonist muscles seen during Parkinson's disease resting tremor strongly resembled the activity seen during voluntary flexion of the arm. This suggests that resting tremor and voluntary movement execution arise from similar oscillations in the motor cortex, which may explain why they do not occur simultaneously.
Finally, the observation that resting tremor at movement onset is no longer inhibited when the cerebellum is absent Deuschl et al. Re-emergent tremor can then be explained by reinitiating the cerebello-thalamo-cortical tremor circuit through the basal ganglia. A beat of tremor preceding movement in Parkinson's disease. Fast flexion patterns in patients with Parkinson's disease.
This is illustrated for one patient. Adapted from Hallett et al. According to our model, transient activity in the pallidum and putamen can trigger tremor-related activity in the cerebello-thalamo-cortical circuit. The pallidum is also activated during voluntary movement planning Owen et al. Movement-related activity may replace tremor-related activity in the pallidum, and this could interfere with tremor in two ways.
However, this mechanism does not explain why tremor is immediately reduced at the onset of voluntary movements, which suggests an active instead of a passive disturbance of the cerebello-thalamo-cortical tremor circuit. Second, the pallidum may actively inhibit the motor cortex during voluntary movements. The pallidum supports action selection by exciting desired motor programmes, while inhibiting all others [centre-surround inhibition Mink, ; Beck and Hallett, ].
Inhibition of motor representations in the motor cortex during voluntary movement selection could actively interfere with tremor-related firing in the cerebello-thalamo-cortical circuit, causing an immediate arrest of the tremor.
This concept may also explain why resting tremor re-emerges during fixed postural holding Jankovic et al. That is, while the basal ganglia are strongly involved in changing movement set, they are not involved in maintaining a fixed posture Cools et al. Thus, Parkinson's disease tremor may emerge not necessarily in the absence of movement rest , but rather in the absence of selection demands including maintaining a posture when no other posture needs to be selected to satisfy the current task context.
Previous work has extensively reviewed the response of tremor to different pharmacological preparations Elble, ; Fishman, , and we will not repeat this here. Levodopa and other dopaminergic drugs are generally less efficacious against tremor than other key features of Parkinson's disease Fishman, ; Rodriguez-Oroz et al. This failure to respond to dopaminergic treatment is difficult to reconcile with most models, which assume that tremor is triggered by dopamine depletion.
One possibility is that non-dopaminergic neurotransmitters play a role. In humans, there are serotonergic projections from the raphe to the basal ganglia, including the pallidum Wallman et al. If both serotonergic and dopaminergic changes can produce tremor, then this may explain why some patients fail to respond to dopaminergic therapy.
Another speculative possibility is that there are crucial temporal windows during disease progression in which the tremor is responsive to dopaminergic treatment.
For example, basal ganglia signals might be required for driving the cerebello-thalamo-cortical circuit into tremor only during the early phases of the disease. Later in the disease, perhaps due to depletion of inhibitory neurotransmitters in the tremor circuit, oscillations in the cerebello-thalamo-cortical circuit might not need to be triggered by basal ganglia signals.
This would predict that the response of tremor to dopaminergic therapy is modulated by disease duration. Finally, one report investigated the effect of dopaminergic treatment on the oscillatory tremor network in Parkinson's disease Pollok et al. They found that levodopa specifically reduced thalamo-cortical coupling. This suggests that the thalamo-cortical axis has a central role in tremor genesis, but that dopaminergic areas such as the basal ganglia control the emergence of tremor-related oscillations in this circuit.
We have reviewed and discussed several clinical and pathophysiological differences between tremor-dominant and non-tremor Parkinson's disease subtypes. We suggest that pallidal dopamine depletion is related to tremor, while other pathophysiological markers could explain a more benign disease course.
First, there is converging evidence from post-mortem and nuclear imaging studies that patients with tremor-dominant Parkinson's disease have relatively benign nigrostriatal degeneration.
This may explain why other features of Parkinson's disease also take a more benign course in tremor-dominant patients. Second, there is post-mortem evidence that patients with non-tremor Parkinson's disease have more cortical lesions than patients with tremor-dominant Parkinson's disease, and this may explain the worse cognitive dysfunction of patients with non-tremor Parkinson's disease. Appearance of such cortical lesions with advancing disease may also explain why tremor can diminish or even disappear after several years in some patients, because the cerebello-thalamo-cortical circuit now becomes damaged.
Finally, resting tremor may emerge as a collateral effect of cerebral mechanisms that compensate for pathophysiological changes producing akinesia Hallett and Khoshbin, ; Rivlin-Etzion et al. Voluntary movement arises in phase with the tremor, suggesting that the tremor may facilitate the ability to initiate movement in the face of akinesia Hallett et al.
This possibility finds support in the fact that—in MPTP primate models of Parkinson's disease—tremor usually appears several days after akinesia and rigidity Zaidel et al. This does not yet prove any causal relationship, but one possibility is that such compensatory changes—for example in the motor cortex and cerebellum—may render these regions more susceptible to pathological influences tremor triggers from the basal ganglia. For example, a study that used transcranial magnetic stimulation pulses to probe the excitability of the primary motor cortex showed that, when tested at rest, the slope of the input—output relationship between stimulus intensity and response size is steeper in patients with Parkinson's disease than in controls Valls-Sole et al.
Although this could be the result of a primary basal ganglia deficit loss of normal inhibition , it could also reflect an attempt to cortically compensate for the slow recruitment of commands to move, by making it easier to recruit activity from a resting state Berardelli et al. Similarly, increased activity of the cerebellum during movements has been observed frequently in Parkinson's disease—perhaps to compensate for dysfunction of dopamine-dependent circuits Rascol et al.
The increased cerebellar activity may sensitize the cerebello-thalamo-cortical circuit to perturbing influences from the basal ganglia, resulting in tremor. This suggests that a combination of basal ganglia pathology i. Parkinsonian resting tremor has a puzzling feature that distinguishes it from other Parkinson's disease symptoms: in some patients, tremor severity tends to decrease instead of worsen during disease progression Toth et al.
Accordingly, patients with Parkinson's disease of tremor-dominant subtype in the early phases of their disease can convert to a non-tremor subtype later on, with PIGD symptoms replacing the tremor Alves et al. This suggests that the progression of cerebral dysfunction in Parkinson's disease may at some point disrupt the ability of brain regions to produce tremor.
Post-mortem work has shown that the primary motor cortex becomes affected in later stages of Parkinson's disease Braak et al. Furthermore, post-mortem work revealed an association between a non-tremor Parkinson's disease phenotype, cognitive disability and pathological lesions including cortical Lewy bodies, cortical amyloid-beta plaques, and cerebral amyloid angiopathy Selikhova et al.
Also, the cognitive deterioration occurring in non-tremor Parkinson's disease [i. These studies indicate that progressing cortical Lewy body pathology may stop tremor and introduce dementia-like cognitive dysfunction. Genetic variations between patients, for instance in the tau gene microtubule-associated protein tau; MAPT , may determine whether patients develop these pathologies or not Williams-Gray et al.
Finally, as outlined in the previous paragraph, patients with tremor-dominant Parkinson's disease might have increased cerebral compensation.
This concept would offer an explanation how failure of compensatory mechanisms in later stages of the disease will lead to gradual disappearance of tremor, possibly because the previously healthy brain areas involved in compensation now become affected by neurodegeneration as well.
We propose that Parkinson's disease resting tremor involves both the basal ganglia and the cerebello-thalamo-cortical circuit. Previous models of tremor have largely focused on localizing the tremor pacemaker in either one of these two distinct circuits.
These models have provided valuable information about the neural mechanisms underlying tremor oscillations in these circuits, but they were unable to solve one crucial paradox of Parkinson's disease resting tremor: why is tremor produced by the cerebello-thalamo-cortical circuit, but only in the presence of striato-pallidal dopaminergic dysfunction? A systems-level view on tremor is necessary to answer this question.
0コメント